You Deserve Each Other

Penn Badgley

— Nicholas 'Nick' Rose

Meghann Fahy

— Naomi Westfield

Natalie Morales

— Cassie

Justin Long

— Austin Frazier

Kyle MacLachlan

— Eugene Rose

Ana Gasteyer

— Deborah Rose

Hope Davis

— Kathy Duncan

Delaney Rowe

— Wren

Lisa Gilroy

— Wendy Duncan

Alyssa Limperis

— Sofia Frazier