Hanna White
— Mary
Aniello De Angelis
— Jo
Tasha Kay Newell
— Molly
Jeremy Chan
— Mark
Martha Downey
— Marisol
Steven Jackson
— Preacher
David Creed
— William
Travis Sturgill-Trahan
— Bruce
Alixandra Giordano
— God
Brandon Suarez
— First Temptation
Kathryn Bogley
— Second Temptation
Lizzie Machabeli
— Third Temptation
Amanda Malmgren
— Eve
Vishaal Diwan
— Jesus
Malcolm Rebel
— Malcolm Rebel
Braidon Hobzek
— Seth
Tino Aridente
— Demon