Seth Coker
— William Carlson
Austin Saylor
— Scott Whaley
Mike Prater
— Jonathan
Chase Matous
— Harry
Emilia Ordóñez
— Liz
Coy Plein
— Riley
Lydia Caswell
— Brenda
Ethan Beattie
— Carter
Cameron Donnell
— Faceless Man
Mia Klauberg
— Faceless Woman
Margot Maple
— Faceless Older Woman
Victoria Gonzalez
— Faceless Child
Zanein Martino
— Young William
Marci Reed
— Tera Carlson (William's Mom)
Koylin Marshall
— Mike (Jonathan's Dad)
Malcolm Hammond
— Stage Manager
Cooper Beely
— Professor
Alex Rapp
— Sam
Fox Nevatt
— Waiter
Izzy Hill
— Partygoer (Halloween Party)
Adrien Arcana
— Partygoer (Halloween Party)
Jazmine Lee
— Partygoer (Frat House)
Lake Garrett
— Student
Lu Buffington
— Student / Partygoer (Frat House)
Maddie Middleton
— Pedestrian
Mia Beely
— Pedestrian
Ethan Stab
— Student (Auditions)
Ivy Neva
— Pedestrian