Randolph Scott
— Jackson 'Sugarfoot' Redan
Adele Jergens
— Reva Cairn
Raymond Massey
— Jacob Stint
S.Z. Sakall
— Don Miguel Wormser
Robert Warwick
— J. C. Crane
Arthur Hunnicutt
— Fly-Up-the-Creek Jones
Hugh Sanders
— Asa Goodhue
Hope Landin
— Mary
Hank Worden
— Johnny Behind-the-Stove
Gene Evans
— Billings
John Hamilton
— Judge Backus
Edmon Ryan
— Narrator (voice)