Scott Cohen
— Charlie / Kevin
Angela Bettis
— Ellie
Svetlana Efremova
— Diana
Almog Pail
— Rabbi Esther
Darwin Shaw
— Lipner
Romyn Smith
— Shane
Inga Stamboltyan
— Zara
Rachel Alig
— Sister
Solomon Alexander
— Michael
Jon Armond
— Charlie Plus (voice)
Boris Lee Krutonog
— Frumin
Mark Sluggo Silverman
— Urologist
Derek Rouzard
— Boyfriend
Joel Solorio
— Dance Instructor