Iliza Shlesinger
— Jamie
Garrett Wareing
— Colby
Lola Tung
— Harper
Cassidy Freeman
— Marissa
Tom Welling
— Chase
Megan Mullally
— Layanne
Jeff Perry
— Randall
Joe Anselm
— Trace
Elliott Campbell
— Jay
Zachary Scott Clark
— Morgan's Husband
Samuel P. Espinoza
— Mateo
Aimee Garcia
— Amanda
Alexa Maria Huerta
— Janelle
Lindsey Moore
— Aida
Jaynelle Veloso
— Lara
Otto Klemp
— Kellen
Kristin Slaysman
— Morgan