Emily Rose
— Jessica Tannen
Eric Close
— Paul Tannen
Doug Jones
— Doug the Deliveryman
Nancy Stafford
— Janie Gilbert
Shari Rigby
— Elisha Moore
Frank Oakley III
— Walter Moore
Desiree Ross
— Aria Moore
Vanessa Benavente
— Olivia Martinez
Angel Rivera
— Marco Martinez
Gracie Bryant
— Melody Tannen
Matt Anspach
— Nick Tannen
Ellis Myers
— Gabe Tannen
John O'Hurley
— Don 'Pop' Philips
Sally Struthers
— Viola 'Gram' Philips
Paul Ryden
— Jack Gilbert Sr.
Grace Schnitzius
— Ana
Ava Jean
— Teen Jessica Phillips
Ivey Asher
— Teen Elisha Phillips
Shun Lee Fong
— Pastor Mark
Stephanie Hearn Purcell
— Organizer
Audrey Easton
— Receptionist
Sergio Lanza
— Alex Martinez
Vseant Nath
— Doctor
Tye Edwards
— Co-worker
Marianne Haaland
— PTA Mom 1
Lydia Eku
— PTA Mom 2
Branden Lewis
— Physical Therapist
Locke Geigerman
— Young Nick
Makayla Kelly
— Young Melody
Liam Kelly
— Young Gaber