R.W. Martin
— Jim Gordon
RJ Farnsworth
— Nikki Martin
Nicholas Kranick
— Batman
Brian Van Sise
— The Shape
Adam Parrott
— Alfred Pennyworth
Amaya Kiliniski
— Angie/Jogger
Joe Martino
— Dick Grayson/Nightwing
Emmy Lansley
— Prostitute/Ashley
Shawn Collins
— Homeless Man
Sierra Flowers
— Colleen Miles
Sarah Beck
— Barbara Gordon
Grayson Kranick
— TJ - (Trick or Treater 1)
Phil Sawyer
— Harvey Bullock
Jill Simpson
— TJ's Mother