Lupita Nyong'o
— Viola
Junior Nyong'o
— Sebastian
Sandra Oh
— Olivia
Khris Davis
— Orsinio
b
— Antonio
Peter Dinklage
— Malvolio
Moses Sumney
— Feste
John Ellison Conlee
— Sir Toby Belch
Jesse Tyler Ferguson
— Andrew Aguecheek
Daphne Rubin-Vega
— Maria
Kapil Talwalkar
— Fabian
Joe Tapper
— Sea Captain / Priest
Ariyan Kassam
— Curio
Chinna Palmer
— Ensemble / Dance Captain
Nathan M. Ramsey
— Ensemble / Fight Captain
Julian Tushabe
— Ensemble / Captain
Jaina Rose Jallow
— Ensemble
Dario Alvarez
— Ensemble
Valentino Musumeci
— Ensemble
Precious Omigie
— Ensemble
Jasmine Sharma
— Ensemble
Adrian Villegas
— Ensemble
Ada Westfall
— Ensemble
Mia Wurgaft
— Ensemble