Penelope Ann Miller
— Elizabeth Hamilton
T.R. Knight
— Mark
Blair Underwood
Anna Paquin
— Gemma
Charity Wakefield
— Jules
Amanda Christine
— Meli Goodman
Thad Luckinbill
— Oliver
Amanda Joy Erickson
— Rick's Hostess
Todd Terry
— Leo Cline
Marilyn Swick
— Upscale Patron
Scarlett Fernandez
— Young Jules
Walter Perez
— Rick Bream
Farah White
— Rose Chastain
Alyssa Gabrielle Rodriguez
— Kate Matthews
Calvin Williams
— Lawyer
Maria Alexandra
— Country Club Guest
Gracie Prewitt
— Young Gemma
Matthew Thornton
— Law Firm Partner