James Franco
— James
Catherine Keener
— Catherine
Fallon Goodson
— Patricia
David Strathairn
— Delmar
Alan Cumming
— Alan
Ken Scott
— Narrator (voice)
Mary Beth Peil
— Blind Woman
Ben George
— Policeman
Carter
— Officer Carter
Jermaine Crawford
— Teenager
Vince Jolivette
— Officer Jolivette
Jon Prescott
— Prescott
Jean Carter
— Lady in Diner
Bob Zelnick
— Mr. Zelnick
Julie Sharbutt
— Drugstore Soda Jerk
Madalyn Lester
— Woman in Cast
Meredith Anne Bull
— Girl in Diner (uncredited)