Danielle Harris
— Marybeth Dunstan
Kane Hodder
— Victor Crowley
Zach Galligan
— Sheriff Fowler
Caroline Williams
— Amanda
Derek Mears
— Hawes
Rileah Vanderbilt
— Dougherty
Sean Whalen
— Randy
Jason Trost
— Hamilton
Diane Ayala Goldner
— Elbert
Parry Shen
— Andrew
Robert Diago DoQui
— Deputy Winslow
Sid Haig
— Abbott McMullen
Ted Geoghegan
— Anxious deputy
Adam Green
— Drunken Prisoner
Cody Blue Snider
— Schneiderman
John Michael Sudol
— Jim
Jamal Dennis
— Fire Department Official #1
Thomas Tah Hyde III
— Deputy #2
Sarah Elbert
— Secretary
Eric Stratemeier
— SWAT Officer Stratemeier
Nito Larioza
— Random SWAT Officer
Guy Fernandez
— Deputy Ralston
Jared DePasquale
— Deputy Jared (uncredited)
Joel David Moore
— Ben (uncredited)
Preston Trahan
— Officer Hyde (uncredited)
Will Barratt
— Alligator Victim (uncredited)