Gabrielle Chevalier
— Terry Perkins
Nolan Winters
— Shawn Allen
Jody William Baxmeyer
— Don Perkins
Gary Shaw
— Cult Leader
Trinity Diehlee
— Bewildered Intern
Marqus Chavez
— News Reporter
Jack McLaughlin
— Police Officer
George Shikowitz
— Police Officer
Nata Aguilar
— Ricky Lewis
Stella Cole
— Cultist
Renn Smith-Shaw
— Cultist
Ivan Castanon
— Cultist
Joseph Montoya
— Cultist
Connor Claspell
— Cultist
Gracie Bauman
— Cultist
Maggie Taylor
— Live Studio Audience Member
Mikel Culkin
— Live Studio Audience Member