Kevin Sorbo
— Sheriff Preston Biggs
Lance Henriksen
— James Monte
Dominique Swain
— Abigail
Jamie Anne Allman
— Olivia Thibodeaux
Jillian Armenante
— Lettie
Felicia Day
— Blue
Silas Weir Mitchell
— Frank
Lucy Lee Flippin
— Woman
Blake Gibbons
— Charlie
Don Swayze
— James
Chris L. McKenna
— Sheriff Logan
Michael Ensign
— The Reverend
Caryn Mower
— Mary