Van Johnson
— Father John X. Halligan
Paul Douglas
— Joe Brewster
Joseph Calleia
— Aggiunto Bodulli
Carlo Rizzo
— Antonio Silesto
Tudor Owen
— Father McGinniss
Mimi Aguglia
— Rosa
Harry Hayden
— Girdle Salesman
Dino Nardi
— Commissario Genoa
Aldo Silvani
— Cabby with horse and buggy
Mario Siletti
— Luigi Lugacetti
Argentina Brunetti
— Mrs. Lugacetti
Emory Parnell
— Ship's Captain
Charles Fawcett
— Mr. Cates
Alberto Lolli
— Father Segatini
Adriano Ambrogi
— Father Mariani
Amina Pirani Maggi
— Dove