Jack Noseworthy
— Anthony
Matt Newton
— Henry Kray
Valerie Geffner
— Izzy
Austin Lysy
— Parker
Lorri Bagley
— Dierdre
Neal Huff
— Marcus
Ian Reed Kesler
— Skip Franklin
Ebon Moss-Bachrach
— Charlie
Karen Allen
— Eunice Kray
Michael Lerner
— Jack Kray
Tighe Swanson
— Sam
Kristen Schaal
— Bookstore Lady
Tibor Feldman
— Therapist
Daniella Rich
— Patti
Michelle Hurst
— Professor Silver
André Vippolis
— Jonas
Mandy Kaplan
— Sally-Rae
Monique Gabriela Curnen
— Female Reporter
Anthony Ruivivar
— Daniel
Frank Bonsangue
— Driver
Dan Moran
— Kray's Bodyguard
Annie Meisels
— College Woman #1