Robinne Lee
— Erica
Sam Jaeger
— Kyle
Sara Rue
— Sam
Amanda Crew
— Amanda
Dulé Hill
— Popcorn Caller
Jon Huertas
— Alex
Jack Briggs
— Mike
David H. Lawrence XVII
— Mr. Koffsky
Beth Grant
— Mrs. Wojiechowski
Gabrielle Union
— Long Story Caller
Benita Krista Nall
— Glue Caller
Nicole Lyn
— Chicken Nuggets Caller
Ahna O'Reilly
— Concerned Pet Owner
Molly Hagan
— Potato Shredder Caller
Joshua Snyder
— Frozen Pizza Caller
Sonya Eddy
— Refried Bean Caller
Larry Marko
— Old Man Stranger
Samm Levine
— Pranked Caller
Jane Fleiss
— Lonely Stranger
Josh Cooke
— Soup Caller
Jareb Dauplaise
— Lawnmower Caller
Michael Chieffo
— Cheese Caller
Adam Lazarre-White
— Blu-Ray Caller
Mitch Berlow
— Lightbulb Caller
Richard Chiu
— Microwave Caller
Monette Magrath
— Make-Up Caller
Dendrie Taylor
— TV Caller
Hill Harper
— Political Nutcase
Sam Simon
— English Caller
John Kapelos
— Creepy Guy