Richard Barthelmess
— Chief Joe Thunderhorse
Ann Dvorak
— Lydia
Dudley Digges
— Elihu P. Quissenberry
Claire Dodd
— Norma
Henry O'Neill
— J.R. Dickinson
Robert Barrat
— Dawson
Arthur Hohl
— Dr. Turner
Clarence Muse
— Sam
Sidney Toler
— Thomas Shanks
Charles Middleton
— Sheriff Scatters
Tully Marshall
— Jake
Wallis Clark
— Cochran
William V. Mong
— Grandy
DeWitt Jennings
— Sheriff Jennings
Juliet Ware
— Mrs. Trevor
James Eagles
— Adam Thunderhorse
Frank McGlynn Sr.
— Missionary
Agnes Narcha
— Jennie Thunderhorse
Sidney Bracey
— Norma's Butler (uncredited)
Iron Eyes Cody
— Indian (uncredited)