Patrick Bauchau
— Albert Fish
Jack Conley
— Det. Will King
John Aylward
— Capt. Ayers
Jillian Armenante
— Delia Budd
Silas Weir Mitchell
— Albert Fish, Jr.
Vyto Ruginis
— Det. Maher
Mollie Milligan
— Gertrude
Eric Parker
— Edward Budd
Lexi Ainsworth
— Grace Budd
Shaun Senter
— Pale Boy
Ben Hall
— Albert Budd
Brett Bower
— Lee Sicowski
Jason Burkhart
— John DeMarco
Lisa Carnahan
— Maggie
Bill Flynn
— Frederic Wertham, M.D.
Shawn Jefferson
— Officer Macdonald
Aaron Kozak
— Willie
Calley Luman
— Gloria DeMarco
Tom Marcantel
— Dr. LaGuardia
Cayman Mitchell
— Francis McDonnell
Dennis O'Neill
— Oscar Downey
Jackson Pace
— Billy Gaffney
Wil Rogers
— Jimmy
Heather Surdukan
— Mrs. Karlson
Paul T. Taylor
— Western Union Manager
Laurel Whitsett
— Miss Bruce
Austin Majors
— Boy Scout (voice)
Colin Anderson
— Spanked Boy