Charles Collins
— Jonathan Pride
Frank Morgan
— Mayor Don Emilio Perena
Steffi Duna
— Serafina Perena
Luis Alberni
— Pamfilo (the Jailer)
Victor Varconi
— Don Balthazar (Monterey Captain of the Guards)
Rita Hayworth
— Specialty Dancer (uncredited)
Jack La Rue
— Lt. Chago (Baltazar's Aide)
Alma Real
— Blanca (Serafina's Maid)
William V. Mong
— Tecolote (Old Indian)
Mitchell Lewis
— Pirate Chief
Julian Rivero
— Shepherd
John Eberts
— Mozo
Eduardo Cansino Jr.
— Specialty Dancer (uncredited)
Nora Cecil
— Landlady (uncredited)
Jim Farley
— Sailor (uncredited)
Cy Kendall
— Bouncing Betty's Cook (uncredited)
Vera Lewis
— Orville's Mother (uncredited)
Ellen Lowe
— Miss Ponsonby (uncredited)
Pat Nixon
— Dance-Class Student (uncredited)
Marjorie Reynolds
— Dancer (uncredited)
Max Wagner
— Pirate (uncredited)
Harold Waldridge
— Orville (uncredited)