Peter Polaco
— Justin Credible
Tom Laughlin
— Tommy Dreamer
Rob Szatkowski
— Rob Van Dam
Scott Antol
— Scotty Anton
Terry Gerin
— Rhino
Jim Fullington
— Sandman
Jeremy Lynn
— Jerry Lynn
Steve Corino
— Steve Corino
James Maritato
— Little Guido
Yoshihiro Tajiri
— Yoshihiro Tajiri
Dionicio Castellanos
— Psicosis
John Watson
— Mikey Whipwreck
Jerome Young
— New Jack
Angel Medina
— Angel
Anthony F. DeVito
— DeVito
Michael Bucci
— Nova
Christopher Chetti
— Chris Chetti
David Cash
— Kid Kash
Dan Morrison
— Danny Doring
Mike DePoli
— Roadkill
Patrick Kenney
— Simon Diamond
Joseph Dorgan
— Johnny Swinger
Christopher Wright
— C.W. Anderson
Balls Mahoney
— Balls Mahoney
Salvatore Valente
— "Big" Sal E. Graziano
Charles Spencer
— Tony Mamaluke (Ringside)
Francine Meeks
— Francine (Valet)
Ken Rinehurst
— Jack Victory (Ringside)
James Mitchell
— The Sinister Minister (Manager)
Matt Hyson
— Spike Dudley (Appearance)