Chad Michael Murray
— The Lone Ranger / Luke Hartman
Nathaniel Arcand
— Tonto
Anita Brown
— Alope
Fay Masterson
— Grace Hartman
Sebastian Spence
— Harmon Hartman
Dylan Walsh
— Kansas City Haas
Wes Studi
— Kulakinah
Bradford Tatum
— Tryon
Jeffrey Nordling
— James Landry
Lauren German
— Emily Landry
Tod Thawley
— Tera
Gil Birmingham
— One Horn
Paul Schulze
— Sheriff Landry
David Franco
— Chandler
Martha Hackett
— Margaret
Mike Weinberg
— Harmon Jr.
Antoinette Broderick
— Julia
Ryan Brown
— Posse Member
Laura Beth Cohen
— Stella
Ingrid Coree
— Hotel Guest
David Guilbeau
— Cowboy
Sam Hennings
— Mr. Hartman
Joel Marshall
— Hotel Guest
Cassie Pappas
— Amy
Brian J. White
— Joseph Freedman