Jeremy Russell
— Devin
Hillary Barnett
— Jeopardy
Sara Cole
— April
Sammy Navarro
— Drew
Michelle Sims
— Susie (Devin's Project)
Ryan Watson
— Ane
David Allingham
— Mr. Dibbs
Kevin Murphy
— Johnny (Devin's Project)
Megan Watson
— Nicole
Daniel Mustone
— Nick
Brittany Elsner
— Haley
Rocio Terrones
— Maria-Elena
Zachary Raderstorf
— Jamie
Wendy Donigian
— Bake Sale Brunette
Susie Granpre
— Bake Sale Blonde
Peter von Pfahl
— Bake Sale Asshole
Marcia Sherwin
— Nick and Nicole's Mum
Preston Peterson
— April's Old Boyfriend
Anna Sikoria
— Flashback Hot Girl in Bed
Jennifer Haight
— April's Mom
Craig Herron
— April's Dad