Jean Smart
— Audrey Walker
Richard Gilliland
— Terry Lloyd
Scout Taylor-Compton
— Young Marguerite
Angus T. Jones
— Tye Powell
Weston Nathanson
— Mr. Willis
Raymond O'Connor
— Minster #1
Robert Pine
— Reverend Cole
Kathleen Wilhoite
— Marguerite Walker
Paul Willson
— Harry
Allison Barcott
— Young Audrey
Samantha Bennett
— Strange Woman
Karl Champley
— Audrey's Father (flashback sequence)
Rick Hall
— Alfie
Carol Kane
— Missy Flanders
Mary-Margaret Lewis
— Widow #2
Kristina Malota
— Charlotte
Michael D. Nye
— Minister
Skip O'Brien
— Paul
Bunny Summers
— Widow #1
Lauren Victoria Craig
— Minster #2
Christian Taylor
— Young Terry