Brian Keith
— McElroy
Robert Culp
— Wild Bill Hickock
Judi Meredith
— Calamity Jane
Jim McMullan
— Buffalo Bill
Alfred Ryder
— Captain Benton
Simon Oakland
— Sgt. Austin Tremaine
Ben Cooper
— Tom King
Trevor Bardette
— 'Uncle Otto' Strassner
Harry Carey, Jr.
— Jellicoe
Richard H. Cutting
— Jack Goodnight
Addison Richards
— Huntingdon Lawford
Cliff Osmond
— Private Jean Duchamps
Paul Birch
— Paul King
Richard Deacon
— Commissioner Mailer
Michael Burns
— Jimmy McElroy
Rodolfo Acosta
— Cherokee Policeman