Shannon Lucio
— Caril-Ann Fugate
Lance Henriksen
— The Mentor
Keir O'Donnell
— Bob Von Buch
America Young
— Barbara Fugate
Brent Taylor
— Charles Starkweather
Al Sapienza
— Deputy Dale Fahrnbruch
William Frederick Knight
— Robert McClurg
Jerry Kroll
— Sheriff Merle Karnopp
Steven K. Grabowsky
— The Dark Man
Rodney Ballard
— Young Charles
George Lindsey Jr.
— Guy Starkweather
Justin Ipock
— Bobby Colvert
Marianne Emma Jeff
— Velda Bartlett
Fred Russell
— Marion Bartlett
Sierra Paris
— Betty Jean Bartlett