Ginger Rogers
— Dolly Madison
David Niven
— Aaron Burr
Burgess Meredith
— James Madison
Peggy Wood
— Mrs. Payne
Stephen McNally
— John Todd
Robert Barrat
— Mr. Payne
Grandon Rhodes
— Thomas Jefferson
Frances E. Williams
— Amy
Henri Letondal
— Count D'Arignon
Joseph Forte
— Senator Ainsworth (uncredited)
Erville Alderson
— Darcy (uncredited)
Lois Austin
— Grace Phillips (uncredited)
George Barrows
— Jedson (uncredited)
Larry J. Blake
— Charles (uncredited)
Stanley Blystone
— Man Outside Courthouse (uncredited)
Harlan Briggs
— Quinn (uncredited)
George M. Carleton
— Howard (uncredited)
Tom Coleman
— Mr. Carroll (uncredited)
Joseph Crehan
— Williams (uncredited)
Jack Curtis
— Edmund (uncredited)
Sam Flint
— Waters (uncredited)
Byron Foulger
— Politician (uncredited)
Jack George
— Governor Stanley (uncredited)
John Hamilton
— Mr. Witherspoon (uncredited)
Jack Ingram
— Messenger (uncredited)
Boyd Irwin
— Hathaway (uncredited)
Jerry Jerome
— Thomas (uncredited)
Joe King
— Jailer (uncredited)
Ethan Laidlaw
— Sanders (uncredited)
Pierce Lyden
— Soldier (uncredited)