Nelson Eddy
— Brom Broeck
Charles Coburn
— Peter Stuyvesant
Constance Dowling
— Tina Tienhoven
Ernest Cossart
— Tienhoven
Shelley Winters
— Ulda Tienhoven
Johnnie Davis
— Tenpin
Percy Kilbride
— Schermerhorn
Otto Kruger
— Roosevelt
Fritz Feld
— Poffenburgh
Richard Hale
— Tammany
Carmen Amaya
— Gypsy Dancer
Irving Bacon
— Peter Van Stoon
Charles Judels
— Renasaler
Ferdinand Munier
— De Pyster
Glenn Strange
— Big Muscle
Percival Vivian
— De Vries