Josh Eal
— Father Asher
Erin R. Ryan
— Aubrie Burke
Dustin Mills
— Peter Cottontail (voice)
Allison Egan
— Sister Mary Agnes (as Allison Fitzgerald)
Haley Madison
— Call Girl (Extended Edition)
Brandon Salkil
— Cardinal Omalley
Dave Parker
— Coroner
Jason Crowe
— Father Crowe
Roni Jonah
— Sister Mary Joan
Minnie Grey
— Sacrified Nun
Janet Jay
— Prima