Basement Jack

Eric Peter-Kaiser

— Jack Riley

Sam Skoryna

— Chris Watts

Michele Morrow

— Karen Cook

Lynn Lowry

— Mrs. Riley

Joel Brooks

— Officer Geoff Wytynek

Noel Gugliemi

— Detective Anderson

Billy Morrison

— Detective Michael Beck

Tiffany Shepis

— Officer Lucille Armando

M. Steven Felty

— Sgt. Pignataro

Nathan Bexton

— The Manager

Kyle Gregory Sanderson

— Young Jack Riley

Nick Nicotera

— Ted the Delivery Man (as Nic Nac)

Kyle Loethen

— Rick

Mark Elias

— Ryan

Jerome Pangelinan

— Steve the Electrician

Julianne Bianchi

— Mrs. Cook

Silvio Fama

— Mr. Cook

Teri Pluma

— Mrs. O'Donnell

Joshua Lou Friedman

— Detective Barmack

Kelly Ryan

— Margie Caffola

Juliette B. Reiss

— EMT 2

Chrissy Randall

Matt Santoro

— Detective Mathieson

Kim Knight

— Tracy Caffola

Joel Weiss

— Dr. Dina

James Williams

— Nick Cook

Amanda Jane Talbot

— Pam Wytynek

Scotty Spinks Jr.

— Matt Wytynek

Rachel Grant

— Darlene Wytynek

Jack Sanderson

— Robert Caffola