Michael Callan
— Steve Braden
Ann Prentiss
— Jill Willis
Eve Arden
— Aunt Theda Reeson
Ruth Buzzi
— Ruth Clayton
Elsa Lanchester
— Gertrude Caruso
Christopher Connelly
— Tony Caruso
Bill Daily
— Peter Garrity
Elinor Donahue
— Esther Garrity
Herb Edelman
— Bert Clayton
Paul Ford
— Elwy Pertwhistle
Herb Voland
— Sgt. Mulligan
Alan Reed
— Phil Haskell
Heather Young
— Debbie Caruso
Barbara Bostock
— Agnes
Ivor Francis
— Father
Adrienne Marden
— Mother
Jeannie Berlin
— Heather
Chanin Hale
— Barbara
William Long Jr.
— Uncle Fred
Vincent Perry
— Justice of the Peace
Celeste Yarnall
— Anne
Lee Weaver
— Bartender
Art Metrano
— Joe
Jill Foster
— Shirley
Merie Earle
— Granny
Duane Grey
— Uncle Larry
Marvin Silbersher
— Harry Caruso
Eve Plumb
— Charlene
Mary Charlotte Wilcox
— Receptionist
C. Lindsay Workman
— J.P. Robinson