Taran Killam
— The Batter
Robby Welles
— The Pitcher
Annie Wersching
— The Batter's Wife
Joseph Campanella
— The Announcer
Jordan Mazzarella
— The Batter's Son
Timothy Prindle
— The Horse Rider
Paul Mazzarella
— The Pitcher's Coach
Bill Bitonti
— The Batter's Coach
Clayton Norcross
— Jonathan C. Edwards
Michael Kirkhart
— Mescal Vasquez
Brando Mahoney
— Jonathan C. Edwards' Son
Katie Canty
— Elisabeth Edwards
Peter Mazzarella
— First Baseman
Brian Schweiger
— Second Base Runner
John Mazzarella
— Catcher
Anthony Sestito
— Player with Mirror