Me Him Her

Luke Bracey

— Brendan

Dustin Milligan

— Cory

Emily Meade

— Gabbi

Haley Joel Osment

Geena Davis

— Mrs. Ehrlick

Alia Shawkat

— Laura

Casey Wilson

Jake McDorman

— Griffin

Scott Bakula

— Mr. Ehrlick

Angela Sarafyan

— Heather

Kyle Bornheimer

— Steve

Rebecca Drysdale

— Kris

Zena Grey

— Pixie Girl

Miles Fisher

Hunter Elizabeth

— Hot Teen Girl

Max Landis

— Party Bystander

Matt Cohen

— Nug Nug Junior (uncredited)

Kelli Barksdale

— Hot Teen Driver (uncredited)

Ashley McCarthy

— Hot Girl in Car (uncredited)

Kristina Hess

— Hot Girl in Car (uncredited)

Marianne Bourg

— Girl at the Bar (uncredited)

Nicole Bosworth

— Goth Girl (uncredited)

Buda

— LGBT Parade Paparazzi (uncredited)

Cassandra Starr

— Reporter (uncredited)