Charles Boyer
— Father Marc Arnoux
William Demarest
— Monsignor Michael Carey
Lyle Bettger
— Dr. Peter Morrell
Barbara Rush
— Terry Gilmartin
Leo G. Carroll
— Father Rector Paul Duquesne
Walter Hampden
— Father Edward Quarterman
Wesley Addy
— Father John Fulton
Taylor Holmes
— Father Keene
H.B. Warner
— Father José Sierra
George Zucco
— Father Robert Stuart
John McGuire
— Father Tom Rawleigh
Clifford Brooke
— Brother Clifford
Dorothy Adams
— Mrs. Dunn
Molly Lamont
— Mrs. Nora Gilmartin
Queenie Smith
— Henrietta
Jacqueline deWit
— Miss Hamilton