Paul Schneider
— Otto Wall
Anna Camp
— Debbie Spangler
Michael Chernus
— Freddie
Heather Graham
— Stephanie
Ashley Hinshaw
— Mildred
Heather Lawless
— Lara
Melanie Lynskey
— Annie Wall
Audrey P. Scott
— Edie Wall
Amy Sedaris
— Holly
Celia Weston
— Joan
Steve Coulter
— Lawyer
Robert Haulbrook
— Real Estate Broker
Melcher Smith
— Dick
Steven Hall
— Doctor
Jeffrey Dean Foster
— Greeter at Church
Beth Bostic
— Ginny
Ben Baker
— Forgotten Man at Reunion (Richard Watts)
Patrice D’Evans
— Liz
Mabel Robinson
— Liz’s Mother
Sally Meehan
— Storyteller at Reunion