Warner Baxter
— Jay Gatsby
Lois Wilson
— Daisy Buchanan
Neil Hamilton
— Nick Carraway
Georgia Hale
— Myrtle Wilson
William Powell
— George Wilson
Hale Hamilton
— Tom Buchanan
George Nash
— Charles Wolf
Carmelita Geraghty
— Jordan Baker
Eric Blore
— Lord Digby
Gunboat Smith
— Bert
Claire Whitney
— Catherine
Claude Brooke
— Man (uncredited)
Nancy Kelly
— Pammy (uncredited)