Joshua Leonard
— Charlie Bradford
Natasha Lyonne
— Lisa Bradford
Halley Feiffer
— Penny Bradford
Carol Kane
— Linda Bradford
Dan Hedaya
— Walter Bickford
Kathy Najimy
— Ethel Bradford
Maria Dizzia
— Sandra
Daniel London
— Miles Bickford
James Colby
— Chuck Bradford
Andrea Rosen
— Betsy
Luke Forbes
— Sandra's Date
Mia Katigbak
— Mona
Heidi Schreck
— Lady in Yard
Maria-Christina Oliveras
— Foreclosed Mom
Rafael Sardina
— Foreclosed Dad
Glenn Kalison
— Mitchell
Regan Lutz
— Young Penny
Meagan Weiden
— Neighborhood Girl
Linda Hendrick
— Dorothy
Edgar Nicholson
— Diner in Restaurant
Emma Hinz
— Young Lisa
Rubbie McAllister
— Charlie's co-worker
Allyson Pedraga
— Foreclosed Daughter
JoJo Demelier
— Young Charlie
Liam Mitchell
— Ralph Clapper
Ellen Levenson
— Garage Sale Lady #2(uncredited)
Jack Noble
— Charlie's co-worker (uncredited)
Natalie Savage
— Garage Sale Lady (uncredited)