Lloyd Kaufman
— Joe The Real Estate Agent
Alyssa Hunter
— Leah (segment "Never Let Go")
Katelyn Hunter
— Abigail (segment "Never Let Go")
Catharina Christie
— Sarah (segment "Never Let Go") (as Catharina Widell)
John Wuchte
— Dr. Travers (segment "Never Let Go")
Eric Lauritzen
— Adam (segment "Never Let Go")
Kerry Finlayson
— Anna (segment "Be Careful What You Wish For")
Gian Keys
— Tom (segment "Be Careful What You Wish For")
David Alan Graf
— The Detective (segment "Be Careful What You Wish For")
Jordana Johns
— The Mistress (segment "Be Careful What You Wish For")
Lauren Lakis
— Helen - Age 16 (segment "Lifelike")
Elain Rinehart
— Mother (segment "Lifelike")
Djilali Rez-Kallah
— Steve (segment "Lifelike")
Kylie Rogers
— Helen - Age 8 (segment "Lifelike")
Lisa Goodman
— The Gypsy (segment "Be Careful What You Wish For")