Peter Pan

Cathy Rigby

— Peter Pan

Paul Schoeffler

— Mr. Darling / Captain Hook

Elisa Sagardia

— Wendy Darling

Barbara McCulloh

— Mrs. Darling / Mermaid

Michael Nostrand

— Mr. Smee

Dana Solimando

— Liza / Tiger Lily

Barry Cavanagh

— John Darling

Drake English

— Michael Darling

Sam Zeller

— Starkey

Thomas Buck Mason

— Nana / Bill Jukes / Crocodile

Alon Williams

— Curly

Janet Higgins

— 1st Twin

Joseph Favalora

— 2nd Twin

Scott Bridges

— Slightly Soiled

Hally McGehean

— Tootles

Tony Spinosa

— Cecco / Pirate / Indian

Randy A. Davis

— Noodler / Pirate / Indian

Kaitlin McCoy

— Mermaid

Kim Arnett

— Pirate / Indian

Jeffrey J. Bateman

— Pirate / Indian

William Alan Coats

— Pirate / Indian / Swing

Seth Hampton

— Pirate / Indian

Steven Petrillo

— Pirate / Indian

Roger Preston Smith

— Pirate / Indian

Daniel Valle

— Pirate / Indian

Theresa McCoy

— Jane