Jess Weixler
— Nicole
Jennifer Prediger
— Olivia
Megan Mullally
— Aunt Kimberley
Will Forte
— Simon
Jeffrey Tambor
— Bob
Bob Byington
— Uncle Robert
Christopher Reid
— Self / Judge #1
Lance Bass
— Self / Judge #2
Emmy Clarke
— Brie
John Charles Meyer
— Reginald the Creep
Sarah Steele
— Sarah
Deirdre O'Connell
— Ina the Tarot Reader