Shawn Parsons
— The Gunfighter
Scott Beehner
— Tommy Henderson
Brace Harris
— Johnny Henderson
Eileen O'Connell
— Sally
Jordan Black
— Sam
Timothy Brennen
— Bill Jessup
Travis Lincoln Cox
— Elijah Jessup
Schoen Hodges
— Gabriel Jessup
Circus-Szalewski
— Ned Schilling
Chet Nelson
— Farmer Valentine
Keith Biondi
— Mr. McCullers
Nick Offerman
— The Narrator (voice)