William McNamara
— Matthew Anderson
Elisabeth Shue
— Natalie
Dylan Walsh
— Michael Anderson
Peewee Love
— T.J.
Steve Zurk
— Father Anderson
Ilse Earl
— Mrs. Piccalo
Ara Madzounian
— Jesus
Tony Fabozzi
— Ford
Brett Murray
— Young Matthew
Justin Taylor
— Young Michael
Jonathan Groves
— Leonard
Sandra Thigpen
— Gina
Glen Trotiner
— Dwight
Jennifer Thompson
— Crystal
Jessica Elizabeth Forres
— Nadine
Estella McNair
— Sara
Edgar Allan Poe IV
— Cabbie
Fred Buch
— Uncle Leland
Eleanor Garth
— Aunt Bitsy
Paul Sylvan
— Cop at Pool
Parris Buckner
— Cop at Pool
Leslie Erganian
— Mother
Jody Wilson
— Deputy Sheriff
Alex Dominguez
— Clerk (Uncredited)
Bently Tittle
— Guy in the Lineup (Uncredited)
Julian Valdes
— Taxi Driver (Uncredited)