Gordon MacRae
— Billy Bigelow
Shirley Jones
— Julie Jordan
Cameron Mitchell
— Jigger Craigin
Barbara Ruick
— Carrie Pipperidge
Claramae Turner
— Cousin Nettie
Robert Rounseville
— Mr. Enoch Snow
Gene Lockhart
— Starkeeper / Dr. Selden
Audrey Christie
— Mrs. Mullin
Susan Luckey
— Louise Bigelow
William LeMassena
— Heavenly Friend
John Dehner
— Mr. Bascombe
Jacques d'Amboise
— Louise's 'Starlight Carnival' Dancing Partner