Josh Hamilton
— Grover
Olivia D'Abo
— Jane
Chris Eigeman
— Max
Parker Posey
— Miami
Jason Wiles
— Skippy
Cara Buono
— Kate
Carlos Jacott
— Otis
Elliott Gould
— Grover's Dad
Eric Stoltz
— Chet
Samuel Gould
— Pete
Catherine Kellner
— Gail
Jonathan Baumbach
— Professor
John Lehr
— Louis
Peter Czernin
— Lester
Eliza Roberts
— Josselyn
Christopher Reed
— Friedrich
Noah Baumbach
— Danny
Jason S. Kassin
— Freddy
David DeLuise
— Bouncer
Thea Goodman
— Friedrich's Date
Lauren Katz
— Stephanie
Alexia Landeau
— Nose Ring Girl
Perrey Reeves
— Amy
Tony Giglio
— Singing Freshman #1
Richard Tacchino
— Singing Freshman #2
Nico Baumbach
— Random Freshman
José Ignacio Álvarez
— Stunt Knight #1
Solier Fagundez
— Stunt Knight #2
Ian Davids
— Ike
Matthew Kaplan
— Omar