Gerard Griesbaum
— Dennis L. Rader (1974)
Eric Gerleman
— Dennis L. Rader (2004)
Victoria Ullmann
— Miss Hatch
Shyla Fernandes
— Vicki
Danielle Petty
— Laci Peterson
Michael Barbour
— Jack
Nola Roeper
— Paula Rader (2004)
Erin Young
— Nancy
Emelle
— Dolores
Crystal Nelson
— Paula Rader (1974)
Christian Behm
— Pastor (2004) / Deputy (1974)
Ricky Love
— Pastor (1974)
Yannis Bariamis
— Detective
Micah Moses
— Dennis
Max Nikoff
— Warehouse Worker
Robert Fischer
— Mr. Hatch
Bud Watson
— Detective #2
Ulli Lommel
— Priest