Ben Gazzara
— Frank Cavallo
Rita Moreno
— Maggie Cavallo
Alanna Ubach
— Peggy
Burt Young
— Bobby
Vincent Pastore
— Joey
Heather Matarazzo
— Donna
Lillo Brancato
— Pete
Shawn Elliott
— The Ambassador
Zach Braff
— Young Fred
Victor Argo
— Tony
David Thornton
— Frank's Father
Chris Orbach
— Frank Junior
Brian Vincent
— Mac
Mario Macaluso
— Young Jimmy
Lisa Altomare
— Italian Aunt
Celia Austin
— Zoe
Claudia Besso
— Joan
Kelly Bishop
— Peggy's Mother
Eric Blitz
— Young Frank
Sam Coppola
— Bill
Mario D'Elia
— Italian Uncle
Joseph D'Onofrio
— Cousin Vinny
Anthony Damica
— Johnny
Marie DeCicco
— Frank's mother
Gina Gallagher
— Dolores
Susan Jon-Koski-Reino
— Italian Aunt
Greg Kachejian
— Vincent
Anna Mastroianni
— Anna
Sara Moon
— Karen
Anne Morea
— Michelle