Jamie Harrold
— Henry Hill
Moira Kelly
— Cynthia
Susan Blommaert
— Gertrude Cox Hill
Andrew Bowser
— Young Henry Hill
John Griesemer
— Charles Casper Hill
Eden Riegel
— Nicole Hill
James Villemaire
— Ward Hill
Sam Boynton
— Young Ward Hill
Malina Dumas
— Young Nicole
Richard Bowman
— Stanley Cox
Michael Kimball
— Owen Cox
Mary Diveny
— Tabitha Cox
Janet Mitchko
— Oliver's Mother
iO Tillett Wright
— Oliver Wendell Holmes
William G. Kantar
— Doctor Bill
Tom Cultrera
— Judge
Frank R. Garzilli
— Judge
Christine Marshal
— Judge
Melissa Darling
— New York Neighbor
Mike Dow
— Nicky's Boyfriend
Rebecca Kantar
— Young Girl
Margaret Kerr
— Young Girl
Chrissy McManus
— Young Girl
Kerry Joyce
— Policeman in Hut
David Andrews
— Guy at Diner Counter
Joe Kismen
— Guy at Diner Counter
Edward Wilke
— Guy at Diner Counter
Marsha Beal-Brazer
— Diner Patron
Cindy Jeffers
— Diner Patron
Craig J. Hunsinger
— Diner Patron