Head Case

Paul McCloskey

— Wayne Montgomery

Barbara Lessin

— Andrea Montgomery

Brinke Stevens

— Julie

Bruce DeSantis

— Todd Montgomery

Emily Spiegel

— Monica Montgomery

Michael J. Panichelli Jr.

— Detective John Haynes

Jeff Watson

— Joe Mitchell

Tanisha Dungee

— Teresa Mitchell

Benjamin P. Ablao Jr.

— Detective Chris Dolendo

Joey Garrison

— Jared

Stacey Lowery

— Olivia Hutton

Dave Wascavage

— Richard Kemmerling

Melissa Torrence

— Karen Wilson

Beth Sikma

— Kim

Erick Kniesler

— Jonathan

Bill Jackson

— Matt

Niki Kehagias

— Marcia

Shree Holman

— Diana

Kate Holloway

— Holly

Jay Cusack

— Jeffrey

Yolanda Irizarry

— Juanita

Debra Lee Wylie

— Victim

Fran Slaczka

— Women's Retreat Victim #1

Sue Morrow

— Women's Retreat Victim #2

Karen Kennedy

— Women's Retreat Victim #3

Mary Brown

— Women's Retreat Victim #4

Steve Brown

— Pastor Vernon Cole (deleted scenes)

Denise Smiley

— Carolyn Jackson (deleted scenes)

John Larsen

— Ron Hayford (deleted scenes)

Chris Keller

— Amy (deleted scenes)