Linda Cardellini
— Leanne
Kristen Schaal
— Nancy
Jaime Pressly
— Crystal Clemens
Skeet Ulrich
— Billy
Patrick Warburton
— Chief WIlliams
Matt Jones
— Matt
Craig Robinson
— Jebidiah
Chris Parnell
— Alan Dickinson
Ursula Parker
— Patricia
Jon Daly
— Donald
Kyla Deaver
— Taylor Collins
Karen Strassman
— Carolyn Clark
Jade Bryce
— Brianna