Zooey Deschanel
— Stella
Aubrey Plaza
— Jean
Anton Yelchin
— Pierre
Alia Shawkat
— Carrie
Ciarán Hinds
— Ned
John Hawkes
— Shane
Frank Langella
— Tim Geer
Benjamin Rogers
— Keith
Primo Allon
— Lyle
Gary Hetherington
— Reverend John Morris
Lucia Frangione
— Luanne
Elika Portnoy
— The Tragic Woman
Amitai Marmorstein
— Donald R. Thomas
Philip Granger
— Herbicide Store Owner
Duncan Ollerenshaw
— Card Player
Frank C. Turner
— Vacuum Salesman
Jesse Haddock
— Partygoer